Research work · 2019
Law of the pursuer
Arnold N. Enker
Routledge eBooks
Abstract
This chapter addresses self-defense in the classic criminal law sense, namely, violent defense against physical attack. It presents the primary justifications that other legal systems have offered for the principle of self-defense. The chapter aims to survey the biblical sources that constitute the basis for the approach taken by Jewish law, exploring their traditional interpretations. According to Maimonides, the source for the law of the pursuer is the passage about the wife who attacks her husband’s adversary. Like other areas of law, the “law of the pursuer” must be examined not only from the perspective of the theoretical law as set out in the Mishnah and talmudic literature, but also from the perspective of legal practice, that is, the responsa literature. Some Tannaim disagree with the Mishnah’s determination that the right to self-defense is conditioned on two distinct elements; in effect, they extend the law of the pursuer beyond self-defense proper and see its thrust as prevention of the offense.