Research work · 2022
Religion, Evolution and Scottish Philosophy
Gordon Graham
Scottish Philosophy after the Enlightenment
Abstract
Hume’s posthumously published Dialogues Concerning Natural Religion presented a very significant challenge to philosophical theism, one of the traditional concerns of Scottish philosophers. While the conclusion of the Dialogues leaves open a bare possibility of intelligent design, the publication of Darwin’s Origin of Species, and the theory of evolution it advanced, seems to close this off. Yet, contrary to this natural thought, many Scottish philosophers in the 19th century continued to articulate and defend philosophical theism while at the same time enthusiastically embracing Darwinian evolution. This chapter elaborates arguments relevant to this initially unpromising combination developed by Henry Calderwood in Evolution and Man’s Place in Nature and by Andrew Seth Pringle-Pattison in The Idea of God in the Light of Recent Philosophy.