Research work · 1998
Climate Discourse Transformed
Historical Perspectives on Climate Change
Abstract
The impressionistic Enlightenment view of the American climate and its changes was rebutted in two distinct ways—literary and scientific. The literary critique was spearheaded by Noah Webster in 1799 and finally put to rest four decades later by Samuel Forry, a surgeon and climatologist in the United States Army. The scientific response came from pioneer climatologists who subjected the growing amounts of meteorological data to statistical analysis. Both approaches contributed to the radical transformation of climate discourse and, along with the expansion of meteorological networks, led to the emergence of a recognizably modern climatology. In his essay “On the Supposed Change in the Temperature of Winter,” Noah Webster criticized the “popular opinion” advanced by “many writers of reputation . . . the Abbé Du Bos, Buffon, Hume, Gibbon, Jefferson, Holyoke, Williams” that the climate of Europe and America, especially the temperature of winter, had become warmer in modern times. His critique emphasized their loose citation of sources, both ancient and contemporary, and the improper deductions they drew from these citations: . . . Men are led into numberless errors by drawing general conclusions from particular facts. “Lady Montague sat with her window open in January, 1718, and therefore there is little or no winter in Constantinople,” is very bad logic. The farmers on Connecticut River plowed their lands, as I saw in February, 1779; and the peaches blossomed in Pennsylvania. What then? Are the winters all mild in America? Not at all; in the very next year, not only our rivers, but our bays, and the ocean itself, on our coast, were fast bound with ice. . . . Webster was particularly critical of Samuel Williams, whose contention that Italy had warmed seventeen degrees in eighteen centuries was based on selective citations from ancient Roman writers. Williams erred in his assumption that reports of extreme weather were representative of ordinary conditions. Webster used historical accounts of the range of frost-sensitive plants—olive, fig, and date trees—to argue that Italy’s climate had not changed since antiquity and “could never have been colder than the Carolinas” and that its winters “were not severe, but mild.”