Research work · 2023

On the relevance of the Hegelian idea of the system of philosophy

Christian Krijnen

Philosophy of the History of Philosophy

Abstract

Despite all prophecies of doom, Hegel's conception of the system of philosophy is one of the greatest insights of this great philosopher. Krijnen shows the relevance of Hegel's systemic thought through a confrontation with post-Kantian transcendental philosophy. After all, the latter wanted to advance philosophy by returning to Kant, whereby it ultimately became inevitable to incorporate Hegelian motifs into philosophical systematics, i. e. also to plea for a “renewal of Hegelianism” (Windelband). Although the attempt of transcendental philosophy to bring about a synthesis of Kant and Hegel has survived into the subject-theoretically oriented transcendental philosophy of the post-war period, it turns out, as Krijnen holds, that the attempt is inadequate precisely because of the Kantian premises under which the intended synthesis was or is carried out. With a view to Hegel's logic and the associated structure of the system of philosophy, Krijnen explains why transcendental philosophy cannot do justice to its own claim to determine the foundations of normativity. In a first step, Krijnen outlines the state of the art of the discussion about the system of philosophy. It is then demonstrated that and why the fundamental systemic relationship of transcendental philosophy is at its core freighted with a formalism that can only be methodologically eradicated by a speculative-idealistic transformation of transcendental idealism. Aspects of the logic of being, of essence, and of the concept play a role in this demonstration.

DOI: 10.21638/spbu34.2023.112