Research work · 2025

Executive Brief: Carbon Capture & Storage Investment Risk Assessment

Finks, Christopher

Zenodo (CERN European Organization for Nuclear Research)

Abstract

Investment risk analysis identifying structural barriers to carbon capture deployment: (1) DAC Economic Impossibility - operational costs $800-1000/t (Climeworks Orca/Mammoth) vs $180/t 45Q credit creates -$620-820/t loss even with subsidy; requires 80-90% cost reduction from demonstrated performance; conservative 2030 projection ($300-350/t Climeworks) still loses -$120-170/t; all DAC is speculative bet on unproven learning curves contradicting operational validation; (2) Point-Source Reliability Failure - flagship projects achieve 60-66% capacity factor (Boundary Dam 60-65%, Petra Nova 66%, Gorgon storage 44% vs 80% target) creating -25 to -35% revenue shortfall vs financial models assuming 85-90% CF; chemistry works (89-94% capture rates) but systemic integration fails from energy penalty (19.9-31.25% parasitic load), equipment coordination, storage deliverability (Gorgon pressure management failure); (3) Permitting Bottleneck - 232 EPA Class VI applications pending vs 11 permits issued with 3-6 year actual timeline vs January 1, 2033 45Q deadline; approximately 220 projects (94.8%) face high probability of missing qualification; primacy states (ND, WY, LA, TX) achieve <1 year approval creating 2-5 year competitive advantage. Infrastructure gap: 5,300 miles existing vs 96,000 miles required creating 90,700-mile shortfall; recent cancellations (Navigator, Wolf Carbon) prove coordination failure not capital shortage. Protected niche viable: high-purity sources (ethanol, gas processing, hydrogen) achieving $40-60/t capture costs with >80% CF potential in primacy states with secured storage (injectivity proof not pore volume claims) and patient capital (2030-2035+ horizon). Market sizing: protected niche $20-35B/year (10-20% of $100B+ modeled broad opportunity); sufficient for 3-5 oligopoly players, insufficient for 50+ venture-backed developers. Investment recommendation: DAC AVOID (order-magnitude cost gap); Point-Source EXTREME SELECTIVITY (five-condition protected niche only). Addresses $50M-$500M capture facilities, $100M-$1B integrated hubs, $2-3B+ infrastructure investments.

Read free full text

DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17619543