Research work · 2003

Skeletal Mineralization: Understood as the Integration of Proximate and Ultimate Causation

Robert S. Fredericks, Nora L. Constantino

The Endocrinologist

Abstract

Science encompasses the art of describing events with numbers and words, then applying those descriptions to the understanding of measurable phenomena. Validating the understanding requires that the phenomena of interest not only be predictable, but also coherent with the whole of scientific thought. Validation of the successful integration of evolutionary narrative, comparative endocrinology, and explanation of the mechanisms accounting for the variance in human body composition, especially skeletal mineralization studied in the context of medicine, is the purpose of this work. Evaluation of mineral metabolism and medical interventions in individual patients permitted the development of physiological models depicting relationships describing a discipline termed structural ecology. A central assumption of structural ecology is that heterogeneity within both populations and individuals is adaptive to environmental change and results in a physiology based not on homeostasis, but adaptive heterostasis directed toward the maintenance of adequate energy. The signaling system for structural ecology is phosphate-based, with skeletal mineralization assuring adequate phosphate to the organism. Validation of the models, termed structural influence models, has been accomplished through the successful prediction of a statistical correlation between variance in bone mineral content at the trochanter and the environmental influence of acute gravitational change on urinary Na+ excretion (r = 0.44, P = 0.004) as accomplished with head-out immersion in water with a group of postmenopausal women (n = 33). Further analysis of the data identifies the presence of antipolar heterogeneity in which subgroups, one increasing and the other decreasing urinary Na+ excretion with immersion, the latter without apparent confounding factors. Coherence criteria are used to provide a highly plausible explanation for this finding, based on both the evolutionary narrative and the originally proposed structural influence models. It is then possible to explore the relative merits of investigative strategies using statistics versus coherence, and descriptive methods, numbers versus words, in the application of data to the understanding of medicine. The structural influence models depicting structural ecologic relationships appear to be useful in clarifying the difficulties arising when attempting to apply the mean values from heterogeneous groups to the individuals, as well as the problem of validating anecdotal evidence with group studies.

DOI: 10.1097/01.ten.0000088383.59810.9e