Research work · 2023
Policy-Making as Designing
Policy Press
Abstract
Approaches to design in public policy and service delivery have turned a corner. Many governments are experimenting with applying all kinds of design methods or design thinking to their primary processes of policy-making, service delivery and decision-making. This new use of ‘design’ is characterised by a process of reframing the problem, mobilising creativity and fostering participation with ‘end-users’. However, too often, we witness a rather uncritical appraisal of design and design thinking without serious attention directed at understanding its limitations and side effects. Moreover, there appears to be a rather deep chasm between the more traditional and more contemporary design approaches in the field of public policy, while the opportunities for cross-fertilisation are not explored let alone utilised. This book aims to contribute to a better understanding of these more contemporary forms of design. In this volume we delve into the evolution of design approaches within the public sector domain, describes the more designerly approaches in more detail, and compare them with more traditional forms of policy design. Furthermore, we analyze their potentials and pitfalls, as well as the dilemmas they encounter. The application of designerly ways of working within a public context is not without challenges. It has to find ways to bridge classical values, characterising a public bureaucracy, and the values of experimentation, co-creation, creativity and the like that a design approach entail. We outline some directions to overcome these dilemmas and to foster a more lasting impact of design for policy and service delivery.