Research work · 2022

The Making of International Human Rights: The 1960s, Decolonization, and the Reconstruction of Global Values

Nordic Journal of Human Rights

Abstract

Over the last two decades, there has been a renewed interest in assessing the history of the Global South and its pivotal role in the creation of international law. This has also translated into the human rights field. In The Making of International Human Rights: The 1960s, Decolonization, and the Reconstruction of Global Values, Steven LB Jensen presents a novel and well-situated contribution to the scholarship engaging with human rights in the decolonisation era. It is novel, because the book focuses on a decade – the 1960s – too often recounted from a Western perspective or overshadowed by other historical moments. The book is wellsituated, as it builds upon the efforts of specific Global South actors in promoting and negotiating human rights norms at the UN level. As such, the book is an important contribution to the fields of decolonisation studies and to the UN human rights history. Jensen is aware of scholarly advancements in both these fields. While he praises the efforts in rewriting Third World diplomacy into human rights law, he points to the lack of engagement with specific aspects of this history, notably the race–religion discourse promoted by countries like Jamaica, Liberia, and Ghana. The race–religion nexus is of fundamental importance for the author to expand the story of human rights as born out of demands for equality, and to nuance the idea of universality brought about by Global South actors. Equality understood solely in terms of political, social, and economic rights, Jensen contends, is fairly reductive. Much more can be said about this story, especially if one takes seriously the contribution of Third World diplomats, many of whom understood that exercising political equality without debunking the racial paradigm upon which the international arena was built, would not have changed the rules of the game. That is why the fight against discrimination and apartheid became the workhorse of Jamaica’s human rights agenda or why Liberia stressed the importance of outlawing religious intolerance through a specific human rights treaty. This also offers Jensen the opportunity to situate his book in contrast with the enduring assumption of decolonisation solely as a struggle for the right to self-determination. There is in fact a tendency in academic scholarship to conflate the end of colonial rule with such a right, viewed as the major achievement of the Third World in the international arena in the 1960s. The author does not deny the paramount importance of the 1960 Declaration on the Granting of Independence to Colonial Countries and Peoples. Yet he explains how the Declaration was a starting and not an end point for injecting new life into the human rights debate at the time. This particular Declaration, Jensen shows, was about freedom from colonial rule and self-determination, as much as it was about ‘ ... fundamental freedoms without distinction as to race, sex, language or religion’ (54). Once again, Third World states contributed greatly to reshaping universality basing their demands on race equality and

DOI: 10.1080/18918131.2023.2176600