Research work · 2021

Philosophy and Eloquence

Donald Phillip Verene

The Rhetorical Sense of Philosophy

Abstract

This chapter demonstrates the sense in which the rejection of rhetoric by the founders of modern philosophy is untenable. Looking to the present, one faces the phenomenon of “critical thinking,” the new and ever-widening thesis of educational theory, namely, that the general purpose of university instruction is to teach how to think critically. The chapter thus considers if there is a way out of this neo-Kantian world that would reduce the love of wisdom to the problem of knowledge. Whenever philosophy, in its history, reaches an impasse, it is because it has forgotten part of itself. It has attempted to reduce the pursuit of wisdom to the attainment of some form of knowledge that holds all that lies outside it to be error, and once declared as error, this outside is forgotten. If one is to recover from the dominance of critique one must bring back to life what has been left behind. Philosophy advances by the power of memory, not by going forward toward novelty.

DOI: 10.7591/cornell/9781501756344.003.0004