Research work · 2026
Mythbusting Cybersecurity Information Sharing and Antitrust Mythbusting Cybersecurity Information Sharing and Antitrust
Elsevier BV
Abstract
Despite decades of federal assurances and statutory protections, concerns about antitrust liability for cyber threat information-sharing persist among private sector entities. This article examines the origins of these concerns and argues that despite the worries, antitrust liability for cyber info-sharing remains a phantom. Through an analysis of federal guidance dating back to 2000, the Cybersecurity Information Sharing Act of 2015, and subsequent regulatory guidance, this article demonstrates that legitimate cyber threat information-sharing does not create antitrust liability. Yet these unfounded concerns continue to chill potentially beneficial security collaboration between competitors. This article seeks to dispel these misconceptions by providing a comprehensive legal analysis of the antitrust implications of cyber information-sharing and arguing that policy makers should focus on substantive barriers to information-sharing rather than imaginary legal risks. This article concludes by examining how trade associations and other intermediaries can facilitate compliant information-sharing while avoiding the narrow categories of conduct that might legitimately raise antitrust concerns.
DOI: 10.2139/ssrn.7509618