Research work · 1987

The Plant Germplasm Controversy

Jack Ralph Kloppenburg, Daniel Lee Kleinman

BioScience

Abstract

he motto of the American Seed Trade Association is First-the seed, and there is much truth to this simple statement. Agricultural production is fundamental to all forms of human society; and germplasm-the genetic information encoded in the seed-is fundamental to crop production and improvement. Plant genetic resources are the raw materials of the breeder. But while all nations depend on germplasm, the vagaries of natural history have distributed genetic resources unequally. Historic asymmetries in patterns of appropriation and use of genetic resources have recently prompted debate at the Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations (FAO) and have fueled a global political controversy. The international controversy that The Wall Street Journal (Paul 1984) has called seed wars could have serious repercussions for both agricultural science and production. In November 1983, FAO's 22d Biennial Conference adopted a resolution with the premise that plant genetic resources are a heritage of mankind and consequently should be available without restriction (FAO 1983a). This Resolution 8/83 established an international undertaking to encourage worldwide preservation,

DOI: 10.2307/1310518