Research work · 2007
Experiencing and Responding to Architecture
Monumentality and the Roman Empire
Abstract
Up to now, this book has been concerned with the attitudes of builders and architects towards architecture, and with the political, religious, social, and cultural factors that helped to form those attitudes. The desire to present a political or family identity through architectural form led builders to create monuments which were intended to have an effect on those who used or observed them. To achieve this effect, however, the forms of buildings had to have meaning for the individuals who experienced them. ‘Monumentality’ in architecture required the possession of certain qualities that appealed to the viewer. To study this concept fully, we therefore need to take into account, not only the intended meanings of buildings, but also their aesthetic impact. In the Roman world, response was an important component of ‘monumentality’ in two respects: first, the monumentality of large public spaces such as baths and theatres lay in their celebritas, or ‘density of use’, which means that they required a substantial audience; second, each separate monument invited ‘contemplation’ by individual viewers; its monumentality depended on their reactions. The final two chapters, therefore, will ask how individuals experienced and responded to Roman buildings. Archaeologists rarely address such questions, perhaps because to discuss the character of buildings as aesthetic experiences seems to introduce an unwanted subjectivity. But Roman monuments had a strong aesthetic pull, and, if we are to understand what they meant to ancient viewers, we must look at them also from this perspective. How an individual in ancient Ephesus or Carthage perceived a building, and the particular emotions generated by those perceptions, can no longer be recovered today. Viewers, no doubt, articulated their sensations to others and discussed their reactions, but such ancient conversations have vanished without trace. To reconstruct ancient experience of architecture, therefore, the historian has to rely either on anecdotal evidence or on those explicit reports of the experience of a building which have survived in literary texts. These written sources are problematic, and cannot be taken as direct accounts of what an ancient person saw.