Research work · 2004

ARISTOTLE ON EQUITY, LAW, AND JUSTICE

Allan Beever

Legal Theory

Abstract

In a famous passage in his Ethics, Aristotle considers the nature of equity \nand its relation to justice.1 His conclusion seems to be that equity's role is \nto prevent the law from adhering too rigidly to its own rules and principles \nwhen those rules and principles produce injustice. Hence equity permits \njudges to depart from legal principle in order to promote justice. In this article, \nhowever, I argue that this conclusion is problematic as it is inconsistent \nwith other claims Aristotle makes, both in his short discussion of equity in \nthe Ethics and elsewhere. Accordingly, I suggest a reinterpretation of Aristotle's \nview that explains more satisfactorily the connection between law, in \nits various senses, and justice.

Download PDF

DOI: 10.1017/s1352325204000163