Research work · 2019

One and Many

Aristotle's Physics Alpha

Abstract

In Physics I 4 Aristotle turns to those who, in his view, practised bona fide natural philosophy by allowing change and multiplicity. But instead of providing a survey of the pluralist options, Aristotle focuses on those who produced plurality out of an initial one. He singles out Anaxagoras and provides a detailed discussion and refutation of his theory of mixture. This chapter examines what features of Anaxagoras’ theory could motivate Aristotle’s exclusive focus on him. It suggests that Anaxagoras is particularly interesting for Aristotle, because he offers a model in which the character that emerges as the outcome of the change is already there at the beginning, without however being manifest. In this sense, Anaxagoras’ theory gets closest to Aristotle’s solution to the puzzle of change. In assessing Aristotle’s objections, the chapter also argues against the widely held view that his critical discussion commits him to the theory of minima naturalia.

DOI: 10.1093/oso/9780198830993.003.0005