Research work · 2009

Arguing over Cinema as Philosophy

Paisley Livingston

Cinema, Philosophy, Bergman

Abstract

Abstract This chapter takes up two Hegel-inspired objections to moderate theses concerning film's philosophical value. One objection it that it is inappropriate to use art to advance ends other than those that are properly artistic. The second is a rationality objection inspired by Hegel's suggestion that it is an error to try to use a work of art to achieve an instrumental payoff whenever some more complete or effective means is available. By responding to these Hegel-inspired objections, the chapter strengthens the case for a moderate thesis concerning film's philosophical value. The chapter considers the conditions under which a sufficiently complex and determinate philosophical interpretation of an audio-visual display can be articulated. In one, non-intentionalist line of enquiry, it is the interpreter who shoulders the burden of creating or selecting assumptions and questions in relation to which claims about an audio-visual display's philosophical significance can be articulated. In the second type of approach, it is the film-maker whose ideas and questions are the target of the interpretation. The chapter applies results concerning the determination of a fictional film's content to the Hegel-inspired objections to the search for a film's philosophical significance.

DOI: 10.1093/acprof:oso/9780199570171.003.0003