Research work · 2023

A Priori vs. A Posteriori Justification

Bruce Russell

Routledge eBooks

Abstract

In this chapter, I criticize Timothy Williamson’s arguments to show that there is no significant difference between a priori and a posteriori justification and supplement Paul Boghossian’s criticisms of Williamson’s view that there are no rational intuitions, only inclinations to believe the propositions that some take to be the objects of rational intuitions. I then go on to criticize Boghossian’s view that rational intuitions regarding synthetic a priori propositions are not based on our understanding the propositions that are their objects. I conclude that rational intuitions are intellectual seemings based solely on understanding a given proposition. They are the bases of a priori justification whether it involves the analysis of concepts, the justification of specific interpretations of those concepts (what Boghossian calls conceptions), or synthetic a priori propositions.

DOI: 10.4324/9781003299349-20