Research work · 2025
Exploring Abductive Reasoning in Mathematics Assessment Items
The Korean Society of Educational Studies in Mathematics - Journal of Educational Research in Mathematics
Abstract
In a society marked by increasing incompleteness and uncertainty, abductive reasoning is recognized as a core competency that mathematics education should cultivate. This study examined large-scale assessment items to explore how abductive reasoning is required in mathematics assessments and to identify its educational implications. The dataset comprised 44 released mathematics items from international and domestic assessments. Deduction, induction, and abduction were redefined within the context of mathematics assessment and used as criteria for item classification, which was validated through cross-checking and further reviewed with the Cognitive Rigor Matrix (CRM). The analysis showed that abductive reasoning appeared mainly in combination with deductive or inductive reasoning and was most frequently observed in PISA items. Although less common in TIMSS and NAEA, some items required learners to make provisional assumptions and justify solutions under incomplete information. Such items were largely classified as DOK level 3 or higher, highlighting their role in eliciting higher-order thinking. The findings suggest the need to systematically integrate abductive reasoning into assessment and curriculum design as a core competency for future-oriented problem solving.