Research work · 1953

AMERICAN BOARD OF PEDIATRICS

Pediatrics

Abstract

The written examination of Jan. 16, 1953, was taken by 607 candidates, a number larger by 30% than on any previous occasion. Grades ranged from a lowest mark of 28.4 to a highest mark of 86.8. After inspection of the range the decision was reached to select 50 as the minimum grade consistent with successful completion of the test. On this basis there were 46 or 7.6% who failed and were therefore considered ineligible for the oral examination. The distribution of the grades earned by the 607 candidates is presented in the diagram. As an aid to visual assessment of the meaning of the distribution a normal frequency curve, computed from the mean and standard deviation of the data, is included in the diagram. Significant is the fact that the objective of the Committee to produce an examination sensitive in the range of low grades and relatively insensitive in the range of high grades has at last been realized with statistical certitude. An examination of this type sacrifices accuracy in the identification of honor students in order to gain sensitivity in the critical range where a decision must be made regarding those who have passed and those who have failed. In statistical terminology grade distributions of this type are designated as "skewed," that is, they deviate from the normal or symmetrical distribution about a mean or average grade. Comparison of observed grade frequencies with theoretic frequencies based on the assumption of a normal distribution discloses that the odds are less than one in 10 thousand that the observed deviations from normality could have resulted from chance alone.

DOI: 10.1542/peds.12.6.686