Research work · 1946
THE ECOTYPE CONCEPT
W. B. Turrill
New Phytologist
Abstract
In two papers, published in 1922papers, published in , Turesson (1922 a, b) a, b) introduced the ecotype concept and its importance in the study of the constitution and origin of species was almost immediately recognized.Ecologists and taxonomists alike appreciate the value of combined field observations and controlled cultural experiments.There was some criticism, in part justified, that the field studies of populations and of the conditions of their environment were insufficiently extensive and intensive and that the ecotype concept was based too much on selected individuals and not on the study of whole populations or of sufficiently large random samples of such.Nevertheless, Turesson's researches have opened up new lines of research and full recognition of his great contributions to the study of species problems must be gratefully accorded by anyone familiar with the facts.There is no intention, or need, to give details of the early investigations on ecotypes.A very useful summary is given by Barton-Wright (1932).More recently, Gregor (1944) has published a most valuable summary of much recent research and trends of thought in this subject.The present paper is concerned mainly with two matters: the full significance of changes in definition of terms first used by Turesson in 1922, and the relation between genecology and taxonomy.Gregor (1944) touched on both these problems which were also referred to by the writer in an earlier paper (Turrill, 1938) and more recently in a review (Turrill, 1942).An investigator is unavoidably impressed more by his own experiences, by the examples with which he himself has worked, and by the difficulties he meets, than by those of others, and the value of concepts, terms, definitions, and schemes of classification can only be tested pragmatically.Genecologists have often criticized taxonomists, sometimes not without reason, but sometimes from a misconception of the taxonomist's functions.Taxonomists have too often ignored these criticisms and indeed the whole experimental work of genecologists, though there is increasing improvement in this respect.The present writer again expresses his appreciation of both the methods used and the results obtained in genecological research and is confident that any criticisms he makes will be accepted in the constructive spirit in which they are offered. TERMS AND THEIR DEFINITIONSFrom the accounts published in his two 1922 papers it is concluded that Turesson at first based his terms and their definitions on observations and experiments, at least mainly, on Swedish plants of some twenty species belonging to thirteen genera of various families (Gramineae, Chenopodiaceae, Carj'ophyllaceae, Crassulaceae, Vrimulaceae, Plumhaginaceae, Solanaceae, Dipsacaceae, and Compositae).On the basis of these studies the three important terms coenospecies (cenospecies in American spelling), ecospecies, and ecotype were proposed.In considering these, and other terms, it is essential to give actual