Research work · 2018
History as Liberation
The Stakes of History
Abstract
This chapter focuses on a recurrent tendency of modern Jewish historians to use their research as a tool of liberation. The first circles of scholars discussed in this chapter employed history to free themselves and their contemporaries from ossified religious traditions. The chapter begins by examining two Christian authors, Jacques Basnage and Hannah Adams, for whom history was a tool to promote their supersessionist vision. Meanwhile, Jewish scholars such as Leopold Zunz, Peter Beer, and Abraham Geiger used history as a lever to unhinge a modern notion of Judaism from excessive dependence on older Jewish and Christian models. A succeeding generation of historians made use of history to liberate Jews of their day from assimilationist biases against Jewish nationalism. The final pair of historians mentioned, Gerda Lerner and Paula Hyman, used history as an instrument in their struggle to liberate women, from both patriarchal subordination and historiographical neglect.