Research work · 2025

Introductory Astronomy Students' Ideas about Black Holes

Astronomy Education Journal

Abstract

Black holes provide a compelling context for investigating how students engage with complex, counterintuitive concepts in physics and astronomy. Despite their prominence in modern astrophysics and popular culture, there is a dearth of research into the ideas students bring into the classroom about black holes. There is also a lack of research-driven tools to document and assess students' understandings of black holes in a systematic way. This study presents the development and implementation of the Black Hole Concept Survey (BHCS), a six-question open-ended instrument designed to identify and catalog pre-instruction and post-instruction ideas held by introductory university astronomy students. Administered to 468 students pre-instruction and 105 students post-instruction across four institutions, the BHCS captures ideas about black hole formation, properties, visual representations, relativistic effects, and detection methods. In this paper, we conclude that the BHCS is a reliable and valid assessment. We report many ideas students have about black holes. These include ideas that are consistent with an expert-like understanding (e.g., black holes form from dying astronomical objects, escape is impossible once one enters a black hole, and time dilation and spaghettification are important effects near a black hole) and ideas that do not match how experts think about black holes (e.g., they relentlessly suck in everything in their vicinity and they are actual pits or holes in space, rather than three-dimensional objects). Some of the student ideas we report have not been previously identified in the astronomy or physics education research literature. These include the ideas that black holes exist for a purpose, that they are fundamentally related to and/or composed of dark matter or dark energy, that infalling observers will be crushed (not spaghettified) as they approach a black hole, and that someone falling into a black hole appears to experience time contraction (not time dilation).

DOI: 10.32374/2025.5.1.153aer